Skip to main content

Table 3 Studies potentially meeting selection criteria yet not included due to unavailable individual patient data

From: Clinician approaches to spinal manipulation for persistent spinal pain after lumbar surgery: systematic review and meta-analysis of individual patient data

Author

Year

Patients (n)

Patient characteristics

SMT practitioner

SMT description

Pfefer [107]

2012

31

"failed back surgery," otherwise unclear

Chiropractor

Multimodal

Gudavalli [108]

2016

69

Age (mean): 61

Sex: 58% female

Surgeries: Discectomy 58%, fusion 38%

Chiropractor

Non-manual-thrust: Flexion-distraction

Lee [109]

2017

120

Age (mean): 41.9 ± 11.7

Sex: 60% male

Most common surgery: Laminectomy 83%

TEAM

Multimodal

Kruse [72]

2011

31

Age (mean): 50.6 ± 9.8

Sex: 50% female

Chiropractor

Non-manual-thrust: Flexion-distraction

Park [110]

2021

106

Age (mean): 54.9 ± 11.5

Sex: 60% female

Most common surgeries: Discectomy (41%), laminectomy (31%)

TEAM

Unclear

Taber [111]

2014

Unclear

"Lumbar post-laminectomy syndrome," otherwise unclear

Chiropractor

Manual-thrust

Stern [112]

1995

8

Previous history of lumbar spine surgery, otherwise unclear

Chiropractor

Unclear

Wirth [113]

2019

12

Previous back surgery, otherwise unclear

Chiropractor

Unclear

Fruhwirth [114]

1992

106

"postoperative vertebral pain symptoms," otherwise unclear

Chiropractor

Unclear

  1. SMT Spinal manipulative therapy, TEAM Traditional East Asian medicine practitioner