Skip to main content

Table 4 Overview of findings from the literature combined with the findings from the workshop described in the present study.

From: The clinical aspects of the acute facet syndrome: results from a structured discussion among European chiropractors

Location of pain in patients with lumbar facet syndrome

Study

local

paraspinal

thigh/groin

calf/foot

 

Fairbank 1981

-

-

pos.

neg.

 

Lippitt 1984

pos.

pos.

pos.

-

 

Lewinneck 1986

-

pos.

-

-

 

Helbig 1988

-

pos.

pos.

neg.

 

Results from present study

pos.

-

pos.

neg.

 

Painful movements in patients with lumbar facet syndrome

Study

flexion

extension/hyper-extension

rotation

rising from flexion

rising from sitting

Fairbank 1981

pos.

-

-

-

-

Lippitt 1984

-

pos.

-

-

-

Helbig 1986

-

pos.

pos.

-

-

Revel 1992

neg.

neg.

neg.

neg.

-

Markwalder 1994

neg.

pos.

-

-

-

Schwarzer 1995

no

no

no

-

-

Revel 1998

neg.

neg.

neg.

neg.

-

Manchikanti 2000

no

no

no

-

-

Young 2003

-

-

-

-

pos.

Laslett 2004

-

-

-

neg.

-

Laslett 2006

-

pos.

pos.

-

-

Results from present study

-

pos.

pos.

-

-

Signs of nerve root compression in patients with lumbar facet syndrome

Study

'No sign of nerve root compression/tension'

No aggravation with straight leg raising

No pain coughing

  

Lippitt 1984

pos.

-

-

  

Lewinneck 1986

pos.

-

-

  

Helbig 1988

neg.

-

-

  

Jackson1988

pos.

-

-

  

Schwarzer 1995

-

no

-

  

Revel 1992

-

-

pos.

  

Revel 1998

-

-

pos.

  

Manchikanti 1999

-

pos.

-

  

Manchikanti 2000

-

pos.

-

  

Manchikanti 2000

-

pos.

no

  

Laslett 2004

-

-

pos.

  

Results from present study

pos.

-

-

  

Pain relieving positions in patients with lumbar facet syndrome

Study

Sitting

Supine/recumbent

Walking

  

Revel 1992

-

pos.

-

  

Revel 1998

-

pos.

-

  

Manchikanti 2000

-

pos.

-

  

Laslett 2006

pos.

-

pos.

  

Results from present study

-

pos.

pos.

  
  1. pos: positive association
  2. neg.: negative association
  3. no: no association
  4. -: not investigated