Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 Rankings of reliability studies per QAREL scores

From: Review of methods used by chiropractors to determine the site for applying manipulation

Article ID Percentile Rank Article ID Percentile Rank Article ID Percentile Rank
Agarwal_2005 26 73 Danneels_2001 18 82 Herzog_1989 37 56
Amiri_2003 24 79 Degenhardt_2005 30 65 Hicks_2003 60 31
Antos_1990 38 53 Degenhardt_2010 66 16 Hinson_1998 22 80
Arab_2009 62 26 Diakow_1988 17 83 Holmgren_2008 85 6
Bergstrom_1986 11 87 Downey_2003 77 9 Holt_2009 32 60
Bertilson_2003 61 28 Fjelhner_1999 69 13 Hoppenbrouwer_2006 48 41
Binkley_1995 47 43 Fortin 1997 13 86 Horneij_2002 46 46
Bo_1997 29 67 French_2000 41 50 Hsieh_1990 16 85
Bockenhauer_2007 22 80 Fryer_2005 78 8 Hubka_1994 33 59
Boline_1988 41 49 Fryer_2006 53 37 Hungerford_2007 32 61
Boline_1993 38 53 Fuhr_1989 16 85 Hunt_2001 22 80
Breum_1995 32 60 Gemmell_1990 46 47 Jackson_1993 64 19
Brismee_2005 46 47 Ghoukssian_2001 17 84 Jackson_1998 26 70
Brismee_2006 64 18 Gibbons_2002 26 72 Jende_1997 40 51
Byfield_1992 29 67 Gross_1998 24 76 Johansson_2006 77 9
Calderon_1994 38 55 Haas_1990 37 57 Keating_1990 61 28
Carmichael_1987 39 52 Haas_1992 72 11 Kilpikoski_2002 46 47
Chakraverty_2007 30 66 Haas_1993 100 1 Kim_2007 22 80
Chiarello_1993 32 61 Haas_1995 100 1 Kmita_2008 100 1
Christensen_2002 77 9 Hall_2004 61 30 Kokmeyer_2002 63 21
Cibulka_1999 24 78 Hanada_2001 24 77 Laslett_1994 46 47
Clare_2004 53 36 Hanten_2002 35 58 Latimer_1998 10 88
Clare_2005 31 64 Harrison_2003 26 73 Leach_2003 69 12
Cleland_2006 46 47 Hart_2007 53 39 Leard_2009 63 23
Comeaux_2001 61 30 Haswell_2004 68 14 Lee_2002 31 64
Cook_2004 37 56 Hawk_1999 29 67 Love_1987 68 15
Cooperstein_2010 61 27 Haynes_2002 22 80 Ludtke_2001 47 45
Cowherd_1992 0 91 Heiderscheit_2008 22 80 Lundberg_1999 46 47
Croft_1994 68 14 Heiss_2004 37 56 Maher_1994 46 47
Article ID Percentile Rank Article ID Percentile Rank Article ID Percentile Rank
Maigne_2009 76 10 Plaugher_1991 #67 62 24 Vikai_Juntura_1987 63 22
Marcotte_2002 29 67 Plaugher_1993 22 80 Vincent-Smith_1999 32 60
Marcotte_2005 6 89 Pool_2004 46 47 Weiner_2006 24 78
Mayer_2004 20 81 Potter_2006 61 29 Woodfield_2011 46 47
McCombe_1989 31 64 Qvistgraad_2007 92 4 Younquist_1989 84 7
McKenzie_1997 53 38 Razmjou_2000 46 47    
McPartland_1996 46 47 Rhodes_1995 54 34    
Meijne_1999 32 63 Rhudy_1988 46 47    
Mior_1985 48 40 Riddle_2002 31 64    
Mootz_1989 32 62 Robinson_2007 94 3    
Moran_2001 48 42 Robinson_2009 54 35    
Nansel_1989 48 42 Rouwmaat_1998 92 5    
Nguyen_1999 62 26 Roy_2006 18 82    
Normand_2007 22 80 Schneider_2007 25 74    
O'Haire_2000 38 54 Schneider_2008 77 9    
Olson_1998 24 79 Seay_2007 28 68    
Olson_2009 42 48 Smedmark_2000 46 47    
Owens_2000 17 83 Solinger_2000 24 75    
Owens_2004 27 69 Strender_1997 (160) 46 47    
Owens_2007 26 71 Strender_1997 (167) 38 53    
Paatelma_2010 38 53 Sweat_1988 5 90    
Paulet_2009 47 44 Tong_2006 30 66    
Paydar_1994 26 72 Tousignant_2001 29 67    
Peterson_2004 55 33 Toussaint_1999 65 17    
Petrone_2003 37 56 Troke_1998 62 25    
Phillips_1986 63 20 Troke_2007 55 32    
Piva_2003 46 47 Troyanovich_1999 94 2    
Piva_2006 94 2 Van Dillen_1998 40 51    
Plaugher_1991 #107 100 1 VanSuijlekoma_2000 24 78    
  1. Summary scores (not shown) were generated using weightings of QAREL checklist items, where weights of individual items were based on the inverse of their prevalence within this cohort of articles. Subsequently, articles were ranked according to their normalized (Percentile) score and their relative position (Rank) within this cohort of articles.